Monday, March 31, 2014

First Generic Top Level Domain Decision - Canyon Bicycles Wins Dispute Over Canyon.Bike Domain

Canyon Ultimate CF MTBOn 5 February 2014 Rob van Eck, a Dutch cyclist and web designer in the cycling industry, registered a new generic top level domain ("gTLD"), canyon.bike, via domain registrar GoDaddy and parked it using the registrar’s own parking service where it featured sponsored listings related to the domain’s keyword (including one for “Mountainbikes.”)

Unfortunately for Van Eck, Canyon Bicycles GmBH of Koblenz, Germany, filed a complaint regarding his registration of the new gTLD via the WIPO Arbitration and Mediation Center, which is then forwarded to the registrar for verification in connection with the disputed domain name. This case is notable because it is the first UDRP concerning a gTLD.

Complainant

Canyon Bicycles is an international manufacturer of racing, mountain, and triathlon bicycles and has been operating under the name since 2001 (the company itself was founded in 1985 under a different name). Canyon Bicycles operates in 16 countries, including the Netherlands. Canyon currently has ownership of numerous trade marks for the term “Canyon” in relation to bicycles (including International Trademark (word) No. 687879, CANYON, registered on January 2, 1998, for goods and services in classes 11 and 12.)

Canyon asserted that the canyon.bike domain name is similar to their trade mark, and so would lead to confusion, that Van Eck had no rights or legitimate interests in the domain name, and that the disputed domain name is being used in bad faith.

Canyon argued that Van Eck is knowledgeable with regard to the Internet and has exhibited interest and special knowledge in cycling, citing the respondent’s professional and social media websites showing involvement in both Internet and cycling-related projects, such as the design of bicycle wheel decals and the creation of an online portal for bicycle shops.

Canyon further noted that the canyon.bike domain name incorporates the CANYON trademark in its entirety, and added that the suffix of a domain name is irrelevant when assessing similarity or identity, but also submits that the “.bike” extension further reinforces the similarity to their trade mark and core products.

Canyon said that the timing of the gTLD registration makes it inconceivable that Van Eck was unaware of Canyon and its trade mark, and that there was no legitimate explanation for the registration other than to mislead users searching for Canyon’s products and services.

Van Eck also made a UDRP rookie error. He wrote to the WIPO Arbitration and Mediation Center on 12 February 2014, in which he inquired as to whether there is a possibility to settle the matter in which “the company pays me for my domain”. This supported the allegation that he had no actual interest in the disputed domain name except to profit from Canyon's goodwill.

Respondent’s Defence

Van Eck’s defence was that he merely registered the domain in order to expand his network and “get in (friendly) contact with Canyon,” curiously adding that many people in the cycling industry are unaware of the new batch of gTLDs that include the “bike” extension, and had registered some domain names in order to “protect companies” from domain squatting. He further noted that the complaint was filed against him before he was able to contact Canyon, and that it is his belief if Canyon went to him directly, they would have “talked about” the disputed domain and he would have relinquished ownership without recourse to the policy. Van Eck notes that he registered the domain with good intentions.
Decision

Canyon was successful in its complaint, and the disputed domain name was transferred to them under paragraphs 4(i) of the Policy and 15 of the Rules. This decision emphasises the need to monitor online brand hijacking especially now that new gTLDs have launched.

1 comment:

  1. đồng tâm
    game mu
    cho thuê nhà trọ
    cho thuê phòng trọ
    nhac san cuc manh
    số điện thoại tư vấn pháp luật miễn phí
    văn phòng luật
    tổng đài tư vấn pháp luật
    dịch vụ thành lập công ty trọn gói

    "Mà toàn bộ chúng ta ở đây, đều là nhân tài thế hệ trẻ của Trung Tam Thiên, cũng là chủ nhân tương lai của Trung Tam Thiên. Đối với mỗi gia tộc của mình, mỗi người đều hết sức quan trọng, điểm này, Ngạo huynh không nên phủ nhận." Mạc Thiên Vân chậm rãi nói.

    "Nói tiếp." Thanh âm Ngạo Tà Vân có chút u sầu.

    "Nhưng, nói hơi khó nghe một chút, vì sao chúng ta lại có địa vị như thế?" Mạc Thiên Vân trầm giọng nói: "Đừng nói cái gì thiên phú, cũng đừng nói đều là do chúng ta cố gắng mà có. Những lời này đều là giả dối. Chúng ta có địa vị hiện giờ, xét đến cùng, cũng là bởi vì gia tộc khổng lồ đứng phía sau chúng ta!"

    "Trong chúng ta, tu vi cao nhất, cũng chỉ là cửu phẩm võ tôn." Mạc Thiên Vân cười lạnh một tiếng: "Tu vi như thế, ở Trung Tam Thiên, tùy tiện phái một vị vương tọa, cũng có thể giết sạch chúng ta! Mà tu vi như thế, phải hao tốn bao nhiêu tài nguyên của gia tộc mà xây dựng nên? Có gì đáng kiêu ngạo?"

    "Nếu chúng ta sinh ra trong một gia đình bình thường, cho dù có thiên phú như vậy, thì thế nào chứ? Bất quá cũng chỉ là người bình thường mà thôi." Mạc Thiên Vân nói: "Chư vị huynh đệ đừng vội trách ta nói không khách khí. Trong mắt ta, những người chúng ta, bao gồm cả ta và Ngạo huynh, Đổng huynh, đều là giống nhau, chỉ cần mất đi gia tộc, thì chẳng là cái quái gì cả! Chó má cũng không bằng!"

    Mọi người im lặng, không nói gì!

    Ngạo Tà Vân ánh mắt thoáng chớp động, nhưng không hề phản bác. Sự thật chính là như thế, nếu phản bác thì lại có vẻ hẹp hòi rồi.

    ReplyDelete